
THE THURSDAY SIGNAL
THE SIGNAL
If you are hunting for European climate money, you are probably looking at Brussels. Most of it is not in Brussels.
The EU’s Emissions Trading System raised more than €43 billion at auction in 2025 - over €258 billion since 2013. Around €24 billion of the 2025 total went straight to member state treasuries, not to any EU programme. By law, member states must spend all of it, or an equivalent financial value, on climate and energy action.
The rest funds the instruments founders already know. The Innovation Fund awarded €3.4 billion to 77 net-zero projects on 19 October. The Modernisation Fund put €2.5 billion into 51 energy projects across 11 member states on 2 July. Those are the famous doors. They are the smaller share.

THE BIGGER SIGNAL
This matters more this year than last, because the other pot has emptied.
Ahead of COP31, Carbon Brief counted what governments have actually promised. Public climate finance pledged to developing countries has fallen by more than 70% in 2026: from around $40 billion a year to about $11.7 billion.
Five countries announced new multi-year pledges. The United Kingdom is the only large donor among them. Germany, France and Japan have set out nothing. The United States is expected to provide no official climate finance at all. On 29 October, before the summit opened, the EU’s climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra described talks on new climate finance commitments at COP31 as “dead in the water”.
WHY IT MATTERS
The two pots behave in opposite ways, and that is the whole point. Aid money is discretionary: decided in national budgets, defended politically, and this year it lost that argument almost everywhere. Carbon market money is mechanical. Its size is a function of the carbon price and the cap, not of an election.
If you are building: a plan that rests on donor programmes or development finance is exposed to a line item that just fell by 70%. One that rests on ETS revenue is exposed to the carbon price instead - a risk you can actually watch.
If you are investing: the second pot is forecastable. The first has stopped being a base case.
THE HONEST LIMIT
These are not interchangeable, and this is not good news. Bilateral climate finance pays for adaptation and resilience in developing countries - work that will never carry a revenue model. ETS revenue stays largely inside Europe and mostly funds industrial decarbonisation. The size of the second repairs nothing about the collapse of the first. This is a map of where the money is, not an argument that it is in the right place.
YOUR NEXT MOVE
Every government has to report to the Commission what it did with its share. Those reports are public, in a standardised template, country by country.
The Commission’s own page on ETS revenue spending carries the per-country breakdown and links on to the full filings. The latest published analysis covers 2024; member states had to file their 2025 reports by 31 July 2026.
Read the one for the country you sell into. It describes next year’s national programme before the programme has a name, a brand or a press release.
Reply with the country you are selling into and the technology. I will tell you what its last ETS revenue report actually funded.
One line is enough. Nothing confidential. I read every reply.
— André
Frankfurt
SustainMotion360 · Signals · Markets · Capital
Pledge figures are in US dollars as reported. Euro figures are not converted, and the two are not compared anywhere in this edition.
